Dear Missy C.
Very sorry to hear about your calf injury... Am I correct if it close to 4 months now, post-injury? If this is correct, then I'm also of the opinion that it sounds like a wee bit slow recovery for a muscle tear. It's a great question you ask - what am I missing? That's a question that should pop up in physiotherapists' heads too sometimes...
When something does not recover within reasonable time-limits, I try to ask myself two things. Was my initial hypothesis correct? What represents barriers to normal recovery?
An "average" muscle strain should be feeling quite okay after 2-3 weeks post-injury following a well managed rehabilitation plan. The chances of recurrence of a muscle strain should be very little for a calf after 4-5 weeks. These are numbers from controlled studies, where interventions are likely to be close to "optimal". For us normal people, I'd add a max of 1-2 weeks on each situation.
Most muscle strains are likely to occur in muscles that crosses two joints. For you calf muscle, that should guide us to the gastrocnemius. The gastroc got's two muscle bulks, and it is usually the innermost that gets strained. It is most likely to strain at the point where the muscle gradually turn into tendon, which should be located close to the middle part of your lower leg. Is this very close to your area of pain? If not, can you describe as good as you can? Muscle strains are usually located within a relatively small area...
A few questions:
1. Did you have swelling, did the calf feel "hot", did you have any color alteration to it initially?
2. Did you or your physio feel a gap in the muscle with the first injury?
3. Did the second episode feel exactly the same as the first one?
4. Are you able to describe, as accurate as possible, what kind of pain you have, the quality of it?
5. How does the pain behave now. Is it only with movement? What level/intensity of movement?
6. Is it painful at night? Is it stiffer in the morning?
7. Any tingling, odd sensations to it when you don't move, has the pain quality or location of pain changed or moved since the first and second injury?
8. Never had previous strains in that area before? Or ankle, knee, thigh, hip, back?
9. Do you have any conditions to your health that might affect your expected healing time? In regard to this injury I'm particularly interested in diabetic or not.
Providing these answers might help me and others to negate or support any hypothesis we make at this point. Obviously, being on an open fora, you provide the information you are prepared to give.
Looking forward to hearing from you again,
Sigurd Mikkelsen