Hi Jim3252,
Sorry for replying now.
How is your pain now? Has it improved? Have you had any instrumental diagnosis meanwhile?
From what you said, it seems like you may have had a labral(SLAP)/rotator cuff tendons lesion. Pain and function deficit may persist for few months and get better with time and therapeutic exercises. Imaging is also be beneficial to better understand what type of injury you had (if any). I suggest to see again a physiotherapist for a new valuation.
Let us know how you are doing.
Reghards