Hi RenderRob,
A number of things come to mind reading your post above...thanks for the info BTW, very informative!
1. Do you have any photos you could post of yourself to help us? Uploading photos of your XRays would also help. The reason i ask is because it is hard to fix something as subjective as posture without seeing it!
2. Good posture is thought of differently by many people. I take a common sense approach to the whole thing...this may be disputed by others (which i welcome) but having "cured" many people of posture problems, i know my way works well
a. You shouldn't have to hold your shoulders or your neck in position - where your shoulders sit is based entirely on the angle that your rib cage sits and the relative length and stiffness of your muscles that hold your shoulders onto your body. Your head sits the way it does because of the way your joints are, how long/short your muscles are and your relative centre of gravity (CoG). Most people have a "sway back" posture in my opinion - where their thorax is behind their pelvis when looking from side on. Because the spine is now tilted backwards somewhat, your head pokes forward to keep looking forward. To solve your head and shoulder posture problems, you need to have your spine in a better posture.
b. In general. your sternum and pubic bones should be vertically aligned over each other - forget all the proper angles etc...we will get to them. This is just the first step.
c. Once you get your thorax and pelvis aligned with your base of support, you can work towards getting your head aligned properly.
d. To make this job easier, your CHiro or PT should be identifying what is tight, what is too long, what is weak and what is strong in your muscles, fascia and nerves. Also, the joints which move too much need to be stiffened and the joints that are too stiff need to be loosened. Lastly, the whole system needs to be coordinated properly to ensure everything is balanced nicely.
THis journey is not hard for me to fix...it is mentally difficult for my patients to do. The most common reason why is that they want to rely on how they *feel* instead of where they are in space. Relying on how you feel is dangerous because the brain modulates the information coming in...you can be in the one position and hold it for a week and your brain will change how you feel even though you haven't moved an inch!
In short, ask your health professional about the following (i am out of time - it is 0200hrs in Sydney!)
1. What structures need to be released to make my posture better?
2. What Muscles are too tight or too overactive? What are you doing to address this?
3. What muscles are too loose or too long or too underactive? What are you doing to address this?
4. What joints are too stiff? What are you doing to address this?
5. What joints are too loose? What are you doing to address this?
6. What alignment do you want me to have? What do i have right now? Why don't photos 6 months later show any difference? Why do i not feel any different? What are you doing to address this?
7. What coordination should my body have to hold me in a good posture all day? Why can't i just "be" in a good posture all day? Why is it such hard work?
8. What should i be thinking about to make this better? Why is what i am currently thinking about not helping?
9. How should i sit? Stand? move? walk? run? exercise? Play [insert your sports here!]?
Believe me RenderRob, if your current treatment was working well, you wouldn't be asking about how to fix FHP on this site! I have photos of changing people's posture within seconds! This may not be true for you but i have fixed some pretty bad postures in my lifetime.
Post some photos and let's see what can be done
Cheers!