ACLs can be misleading in both xrays and Wikipedia reference-linkMRIs. They can also heal themselves sometimes, given enough time. So, in effect, both men may be right in their diagnoses. You'll not lose a lot by waiting and seeing if things right themselves. However, having surgery when it's not entirely necessary could lead to early onset of arthritis. I would caution patience. It'll not get worse and might even get better.


BTW, I wouldn't put so much weight on a person's letters as I would on the facts of their medical practice. For instance, how many ACL reconstructions do either of these men do in a year? (500+ would be my absolute minimum) What are their good outcomes percentage-wise, and their poor outcomes. What's their infection rate? You need to ask them these questions, not just look at the diplomas on their walls! Just a suggestion!