Conflicting advise - hanging "shoulder roll" exercise for mobility? Video inside

[Dwaynehoover]

Hello! I am a rock climber who was recently advised to try this hanging shoulder roll exercise for scapular mobility (video below). However, I've been told one million times to never do pull ups/chin ups from full extension because it puts undue stress on the shoulder joint. This motion looks like the first step of that progression.

So I am curious if this sort of exercise is dangerous or safe -- and why?


Thank you for your help, video below:


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zbtZI8jmcO4

Similar Threads:

• "frayed ankle tendon" and "bouncing" arm when using
• HELP! I need to find a placement for a "period of adaptation" required by the HPC!!!
• Help with bony " hump" or vertebrae sticking out of the back of my neck..
• PCE (written component) "Logic" questions
• "Non-Surgical" Hip Replacement - muscle manipulation