To All:

Please read the original post.

The agreement has been reached that the original post was correct. All of the Wikipedia reference-linkSIJ testing reveals little or not SIJ problems. That was the post. Further, the original post was that the PSIS to sacrum with hip ABD disproves the idea of a stuck SIJ in the same test where a stuck was shown with hip flexion or torso flexion.

The one test shows movement: The other is said to show a "stuck" joint or "fixation" of the joint. Which it has been admitted the older test is in error in.

No one has tried the hip ABD test according to Andry Vleeming, Ola Grimsby, Jim Rivard, etc., etc., etc., etc., etc., etc., If no one has tried it then maybe they should.

If results differ, then what are the possible reasons for the differences instead of just dismissing the newer test, because we are comfortable with the older one and quote others to prove why we like the older test?

That is the point.

This was to be an "open" discussion and not a qoute everyone from here to Timbuctoo. There is no peer review of this, because everyoneelse is chasing the SIJ and no one has tried this testing method.

As for my intentions, they were to bring something new to the forum. In that, it has been successful, because no one has been doing a pelvic assesment with hip ABD. That is a totaly new thought.

Try it with an open mind.

Best regards,

Neuromuscular.